The Take
Mike's Amazing Mayonnaise is not healthy. It leads with canola and soy oil, then buries egg yolks under sugar, natural flavors, and calcium disodium EDTA.
Taste tests describe it as bitter, overly acidic, and one-note, which matches a product designed for shelf life and cost rather than flavor or nutrition.
The Verdict
This is classic seed-oil sludge dressed up with a folksy name and cage-free egg claims. The real ingredients sit low on the list while refined vegetable oils and preservatives do the heavy lifting.
Ancestors used lard or olive oil for a reason. Modern grocery mayo exists to move cheap commodity oils.
Skip it. Buy Primal Kitchen Avocado Oil Mayo instead.
Common Questions
Does Mike's Amazing Mayonnaise have seed oils?
Yes. Canola and soy oil lead the ingredient list in the standard version.
Is Mike's Amazing Mayonnaise ultra-processed?
Yes. Refined seed oils plus multiple additives place it firmly in that category.
What makes the avocado version different?
It swaps in avocado oil as the primary fat with fewer industrial additives.
