The Take
Order eggs any style with bacon or sausage and skip the toast and home fries at Peter's Diner. The Slop Score sits at 71 for this standard Amityville grease trap with zero transparency on oils or sourcing.
It's a real local spot at 236 Broadway since forever, but the menu stays classic eggs, burgers, pancakes, and coffee with no upgrades or claims.
The Verdict
This is a basic local diner that delivers exactly what the name promises without any modern virtue signaling on ingredients. Order the based breakfast and avoid the fryer slop.
Slop Score: 71
Common Questions
Is Peter's Diner healthy?
No. Classic grease trap with no sourcing details.
What should you avoid at Peter's Diner?
Burgers, fries, and anything off the flat-top or fryer.
Does Peter's Diner use seed oils?
Unknown. Zero transparency on cooking fats or ingredients.
