The Take
Order the large cheese or pepperoni on their homemade crust with a sub on the side. Slop Score lands at 42.
This is the classic mom-pop NY-style spot that still makes its own dough and bread while most places phone it in. The rebrand to Fat Cat Pizza + Dogs changed the sign but not the core appeal of huge loaded pies and solid subs.
The Verdict
Get the large cheese or pepperoni on homemade crust and pair it with a sub. Avoid fried apps or heavy processed toppings.
Ask about garlic knots or off-menu homemade specials. Slop Score 42.
Common Questions
Is Original Pizza II healthy?
No. Standard seed oil prep and thin sourcing info keep it firmly mid.
Does Original Pizza II use seed oils?
Yes. Typical for pizza joints without transparent oil swaps or alternatives.
What happened to the Original Pizza II name?
It now runs as Fat Cat Pizza + Dogs but keeps the same homemade dough and menu hits.
