The Take
Order the pepperoni pie and head straight to the bourbon at Goodfellas Pizzeria. The hand-tossed crust defaults to industrial seed oils with zero transparency, exactly like every other local joint chasing the NY-style label.
Nostalgia buyers and strip-mall traditionalists keep this 20-year formula alive. Real toppings and calzones offer minor redemption while the basement bar provides the only real draw.
The Verdict
The pie works if you keep it simple. Everything else drags the experience back into standard industrial territory.
Order the 12-inch pepperoni pie, hold the extras, and ask for the Wiseguy Lounge basement bar if open.
Common Questions
Is Goodfellas Pizzeria healthy?
No. Default dough and zero oil transparency make clean eating impossible.
Does Goodfellas Pizzeria use seed oils?
Yes. The hand-tossed crust uses the standard industrial default with no alternatives noted.
Where is the Wiseguy Lounge at Goodfellas Pizzeria?
Basement bar. Ask staff if open for better drinks away from the main room.
