The Take
Order the cheese slice or plain pie and skip the wings at Goodfellas Pizza & Wings. Real cheese earns the spot its local cred while the rest stays standard Atlanta joint fare.
Buyers signal neighborhood loyalty and avoidance of big-chain pizza rather than any health halo or status flex.
The Verdict
The cheese pie stands out for actual cheese in a sea of industrial pies. Everything else, especially the wings, falls into predictable processed territory.
Order the cheese pie and ask for olive oil drizzle if available.
Common Questions
Does Goodfellas Pizza & Wings use seed oils?
Yes on the wings by default.
What should you avoid at Goodfellas Pizza & Wings?
The fried wings basket and anything breaded.
Does Goodfellas Pizza & Wings have real cheese options?
Yes, per reviews on the plain and cheese pies.
