The Take
Anderson's Frozen Custard earns a 48 Slop Score. The all-natural roast beef on kimmelweck stands out while the rest of the menu leans into typical comfort slop.
Get the award-winning beef sandwich and pair it with custard if you want the real Buffalo move. Skip anything that comes out of the standard fryer setup.
The Verdict
The beef on weck is the only thing worth the trip. Everything else plays it safe with industrial fryer classics that tank the overall experience.
Buy the roast beef on weck. Skip the chicken tender sandwiches and curly fries. Slop Score: 48.
Common Questions
Is Anderson's Frozen Custard healthy?
No. The menu leans heavy on comfort slop classics despite the solid beef.
What should you avoid at Anderson's Frozen Custard?
Chicken tender sandwiches and curly fries. They are standard fried fare.
Does Anderson's Frozen Custard make its own custard?
Yes. Flavors rotate daily across the seven locations and beat industrial soft serve.
